Do Apple’s environmental claims live up to its own highly polished hype? – TechCrunch
Comment
Apple kicked off its annual iPhone extravaganza with a slickly produced, Octavia Spencer–starring video espousing its environmental bonafides. So it’s perhaps unsurprising that most commentary skewed toward skepticism.
And not without good reason. Apple is the world’s most valuable company. It didn’t get there by telling people to buy less. Plus, greenwashing is a time-honored tradition. Corporate environmental claims are met with skepticism by default.
But there’s reason to believe that Apple might actually mean it.
Since Tim Cook took over the helm in 2011, Apple has become increasingly ambitious (and vocal) about improving its environmental performance. First the company bought enough renewable energy to power its direct operations. In 2016, it started using recycled materials in its products, starting with tin solder on the iPhone 6S logic board. Then in 2020, the company set a goal of zeroing out the carbon emissions of all its products by 2030.
It’s a significant goal, and one that Apple should be held to. While there are still seven years until the deadline, so far the company has made solid progress on it.
Apple’s approach to getting to net zero for its products is notable in that it extends to third-party manufacturers, shipping and even consumer use — deep into Scope 3 territory.
Of all the carbon pollution a company has to eliminate, Scope 3 emissions — those that the company has no direct control over — are by far the hardest. Companies have limited control over how third-party suppliers power their factories and offices or source their materials, making it a challenging part of the equation. But they do have some leverage through the contracts they sign. And in contract negotiations, Apple tends to have a lot of leverage.
Fortunately for Apple, its products require a lot of electricity to manufacture. Chips are especially energy-intensive to produce, making up a significant fraction of each product’s overall carbon footprint. Semiconductor manufacturing isn’t squeaky clean, but it also isn’t dependent on dirty fossil fuels like aviation or steel manufacturing. An electron is an electron, and a semiconductor fab doesn’t care if it’s run on fossil or renewable power so long as it gets what it needs. Eliminating those emissions isn’t necessarily cheap or easy, but it’s a problem for which a straightforward solution exists. Not every industry has that luxury today.
Consumers sign no such contracts with Apple, though, and so the company doesn’t have the same leverage to force them to buy renewable power. Even if they did, it’s not feasible yet everywhere. The electricity people use to charge their devices can come from almost anything. It might be solar or wind, but it also might be the brownest, dirtiest coal imaginable.
Apple’s solution is simple and elegant: Invest in renewable power on behalf of the consumer. By adding new, carbon-free generating capacity to the grid — enough to charge each Apple Watch for its expected life — the company is effectively eliminating emissions for which it previously had no direct or even indirect control. The grid might be greening, but to meet a net-zero goal anytime in the next couple decades, companies will need to move faster than the grid allows. Directly investing in renewables for consumers lets Apple get there faster and speeds overall decarbonization in the process.
The other thing Apple did right is that it reduced first and offset second. It did buy offsets (more on that later), but by trimming the footprint first, it went after what’s actually driving the carbon impact of the Series 9 rather than rely on offsets, which in many ways are the easy way out.
Now, a few caveats: Apple is offsetting the 22% of the footprint that it couldn’t eliminate. Ideally, that figure would be smaller and best if it approached zero. But the economy is nowhere near fully circular, so offsets are the least bad option. Still, they’re not perfect. Recently, Verra, the largest issuer of voluntary carbon credits, was caught reportedly selling offsets for forests that were at no risk of destruction, making them effectively worthless. Apple doesn’t appear to rely solely on Verra, and no doubt the company does its own due diligence on any projects it funds. Yet the fact that such a scandal could exist illustrates just how much further voluntary carbon markets have to go.
The new Apple Watch is a first step, and while it’s a modest one, it’s exactly where you’d expect Apple to start. The company doesn’t dive headfirst into changes. Rather, it tests new directions in one part of its lineup. Apple Silicon didn’t burst onto the scene all at once; it started in the iPhone. The company debuted sapphire glass on its iPhone camera lenses first, and once it became confident in its manufacturers’ abilities, it rolled it out on the Watch. Recycled materials have followed the same path, starting with small pieces before working their way into major components.
In many ways, the Apple Watch is the perfect product for the company to tackle first. Its components and manufacturing techniques mirror the iPhone’s and the Mac’s, just on a smaller scale. Why not start small and use the product to work out the kinks before betting big on something like the iPhone?
Nobody expects a country’s economy to decarbonize in a few years, and the same should be true of a company like Apple. (Its annual revenue is about the same as Denmark’s GDP, so it isn’t a horrible comparison.) Perhaps the heavy-handed marketing wasn’t to people’s liking, which, fair. But the fact remains that Apple is at the vanguard. The climate would benefit from other companies following the company’s lead.
That’s not to say that Apple gets a free pass. Should it be praised for its actions? In this case, I’d argue yes. Yet on the other hand, the company has set some very aggressive targets, and it’s absolutely fair for consumers and the press to hold them to that. As Ronald Reagan once said: Trust, but verify.
Every weekday and Sunday, you can get the best of TechCrunch’s coverage.
Startups are the core of TechCrunch, so get our best coverage delivered weekly.
The latest Fintech news and analysis, delivered every Tuesday.
TechCrunch Mobility is your destination for transportation news and insight.
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice.
President Joe Biden has vetoed H.J.Res. 109, a congressional resolution that would have overturned the Securities and Exchange Commission’s current approach to banks and crypto. Specifically, the resolution targeted the…
Featured Article
How large a role humanoids will play in that ecosystem is, perhaps, the biggest question on everyone’s mind at the moment.
Featured Article
VCs are clamoring to invest in hot AI companies, willing to pay exorbitant share prices for coveted spots on their cap tables. Even so, most aren’t able to get into such deals at all. Yet, small, unknown investors, including family offices and high-net-worth individuals, have found their own way to get shares of the hottest…
The fashion industry has a huge problem: Despite many returned items being unworn or undamaged, a lot, if not the majority, end up in the trash. An estimated 9.5 billion…
Tumblr officially shut down “Tips,” an opt-in feature where creators could receive one-time payments from their followers. As of today, the tipping icon has automatically disappeared from all posts and…
Generative AI improvements are increasingly being made through data curation and collection — not architectural — improvements. Big Tech has an advantage.
Keeping up with an industry as fast-moving as AI is a tall order. So until an AI can do it for you, here’s a handy roundup of recent stories in the world…
Jasper Health, a cancer care platform startup, laid off a substantial part of its workforce, TechCrunch has learned.
Featured Article
Live Nation says its Ticketmaster subsidiary was hacked. A hacker claims to be selling 560 million customer records.
Featured Article
An autonomous pod. A solid-state battery-powered sports car. An electric pickup truck. A convertible grand tourer EV with up to 600 miles of range. A “fully connected mobility device” for young urban innovators to be built by Foxconn and priced under $30,000. The next Popemobile. Over the past eight years, famed vehicle designer Henrik Fisker…
Late Friday afternoon, a time window companies usually reserve for unflattering disclosures, AI startup Hugging Face said that its security team earlier this week detected “unauthorized access” to Spaces, Hugging…
Featured Article
Using stalkerware is creepy, unethical, potentially illegal, and puts your data and that of your loved ones in danger.
The design brief was simple: each grind and dry cycle had to be completed before breakfast. Here’s how Mill made it happen.
Google is embarrassed about its AI Overviews, too. After a deluge of dunks and memes over the past week, which cracked on the poor quality and outright misinformation that arose…
Welcome to Startups Weekly — Haje‘s weekly recap of everything you can’t miss from the world of startups. Sign up here to get it in your inbox every Friday. In…
The product, which ZeroMark calls a “fire control system,” has two components: a small computer that has sensors, like lidar and electro-optical, and a motorized buttstock.
The RAW Dating App aims to shake up the dating scheme by shedding the fake, TikTok-ified, heavily filtered photos and replacing them with a more genuine, unvarnished experience. The app…
Yes, we’re calling it “ThreadsDeck” now. At least that’s the tag many are using to describe the new user interface for Instagram’s X competitor, Threads, which resembles the column-based format…
Japanese crypto exchange DMM Bitcoin confirmed on Friday that it had been the victim of a hack resulting in the theft of 4,502.9 bitcoin, or about $305 million. According to…
This is not a drill! Today marks the final day to secure your early-bird tickets for TechCrunch Disrupt 2024 at a significantly reduced rate. At midnight tonight, May 31, ticket…
Instagram is testing a way for creators to experiment with reels without committing to having them displayed on their profiles, giving the social network a possible edge over TikTok and…
U.S. federal regulators have requested more information from Zoox, Amazon’s self-driving unit, as part of an investigation into rear-end crash risks posed by unexpected braking. The National Highway Traffic Safety…
You thought the hottest rap battle of the summer was between Kendrick Lamar and Drake. You were wrong. It’s between Canva and an enterprise CIO. At its Canva Create event…
Voice cloning startup ElevenLabs introduced a new tool for users to generate sound effects through prompts today after announcing the project back in February.
We caught up with Antler founder and CEO Magnus Grimeland about the startup scene in Asia, the current tech startup trends in the region and investment approaches during the rise…
Temu is to face Europe’s strictest rules after being designated as a “very large online platform” under the Digital Services Act (DSA).
Meta has been banned from launching features on Facebook and Instagram that would have collected data on voters in Spain using the social networks ahead of next month’s European Elections.…
Stripe, the world’s most valuable fintech startup, said on Friday that it will temporarily move to an invite-only model for new account sign-ups in India, calling the move “a tough…
The 2024 election is likely to be the first in which faked audio and video of candidates is a serious factor. As campaigns warm up, voters should be aware: voice…
When Alex Ewing was a kid growing up in Purcell, Oklahoma, he knew how close he was to home based on which billboards he could see out the car window.…
Powered by WordPress VIP
